Bullpen squanders Woo gem as Mariners get swept by Yankees

Just when you thought Mariners pitching was coming around...

The Mariners were swept by the Yankees on the road in the Bronx this week, in what can only be described as a thorough drubbing of a series.

With a chance to preserve a game on Thursday, Bryan Woo carried a no-hit bid into the eighth inning before finally exiting, allowing only two runs on two hits. It was the first time in his career that he continued a start into the eighth inning.

Matt Brash allowed a two-run homer to Giancarlo Stanton after replacing Woo, but was able to limit the damage to that, holding a 5-3 lead as the game headed into the ninth.

The Mariners would go down without a threat in the ninth and turned to Andrés Muñoz to attempt to close it out. This is where everything went south.

Muñoz didn’t have his best stuff. He also appeared to be tipping his pitches to the heart of the Yankees’ lineup. To make matters' even worse, the strike zone was inconsistent in the ninth inning with multiple missed calls impacting plate appearances in favor of both teams.

After allowing the tying runs to score following a string of base hits and walks, a sacrifice fly to center by Aaron Judge was able to just barely push across Anthony Volpe to score the winning run for the Yankees. Julio Rodríguez’s throw home was a dime, but Volpe pulled out a swim move to avoid the tag by Cal Raleigh.

Run prevention was the issue for the Mariners in both of the first two games of the series.

Despite a 0-0 score heading into a rain delay, Logan Gilbert allowed the Yankees to break through following the short break from action, allowing a combined five runs in the fifth and sixth inning. Casey Legumina entered in relief, but was unable to stop the bleeding, giving up five runs of his own in one inning of work. The Mariners would ultimately lose 10-3 despite scoring several runs late, two of which came across on Raleigh’s 36th homer of the season.

In the second game Wednesday, the Mariners fell into a hole much quicker. Logan Evans, in his second start since being recalled from Triple-A Tacoma, gave up hard contact aplenty to the Yankees’ star-studded lineup, putting the M’s down three runs early. The Mariners attempted to chip away as the game went on, but were unable to put up enough zeros against the Yankees. Evans ended up allowing six runs in 4.2 innings as the Mariners lost 9-6.

Overall — not an ideal series. The Yankees had not been playing well of late. The Mariners were coming off one of their few sweeps, which featured some sparkling pitching performances. They couldn’t keep it rolling, though, and they now face the tough proposition of closing out the first half against the best team in baseball — the Detroit Tigers.

The series sweep, paired with a Red Sox win streak, has knocked the Mariners out of the final playoff spot in the American League. In perhaps the only silver lining I can find from this week, the Astros saw their recent run of form come to a screeching halt as they were swept by the Guardians. Their division lead remains at seven games.

AL West & Wild Card Standings

Astros swept by the Guardians, so the Mariners lose no ground in the division despite being swept by the Yankees.

Mariners fell out of playoff position. Teams from the AL East currently hold all three wild card spots. M’s are now a game back of the Red Sox for the final spot.

Compass Points: Julio Rodríguez is underperforming — but direct your grievances elsewhere

Centerfielder Julio Rodríguez was branded as a potential superstar from the beginning. He was watched closely by fans as a prospect. He forced the M’s hand into giving him a roster spot out of Spring Training in 2022, and he won the American League Rookie of the Year that season in the process.

It’s no secret, however, that Rodríguez has struggled to replicate this success in the years that have followed. 2022 remains Julio’s best season in the Majors. Not only that, but his yearly offensive production has steadily declined each of his seasons in the Majors to this point.

Season

wRC+

OPS

2022

148

.853

2023

129

.818

2024

116

.734

2025 (thru 93 games)

98

.687

To be fair to him, each of his first three seasons have featured a patented summer hot streak that has propelled the team in the later months. We just haven’t seen it yet this season. However, this, in and of itself, is a problem.

The Mariners cannot wait around for Julio’s hot streak to come. It has happened every year to this point, sure, but there’s still no guarantee it will happen. He continues to hit almost every day in the two-spot in the order — a spot in today’s game that often gets reserved for a team’s best hitter. The argument cannot be made that Julio is the Mariners’ best hitter right now. Frankly, he hasn’t been the entire year — even when he was producing more early on.

He needs to be moved down in the order until something changes. That’s the truth of the matter. It probably should’ve happened earlier, and it definitely needs to happen now that he is slumping — hard. Since the beginning of June, he is putting up a 79 wRC+. In other words, his production has been 21% below the Major League average in that timeframe. In that same span, Raleigh has been more valuable than any player in baseball with a 2.1 fWAR and a 170 wRC+. Randy Arozarena has also put up a 158 wRC+ in this span.

Some of the reluctance probably comes from wanting to put him in the leadoff spot, but that spot being occupied by J.P. Crawford, who is also having a monster year by his standards with a 131 wRC+. They don’t want to move him down in the order and deal with whatever psychological effects that could have on Julio. At the rate we are going, though, I don’t see how they would even have a choice.

This lineup has a whole bunch of hitters that are producing more and have been most of the year. It’s time to make that move. He’s a phenom athlete and still very young. He has wowed us before. If he can figure it out, he will move back up in no time. But we are in year 10 of this regime — they need to win right now. We can’t be waiting and hoping he finds it in the next two months. Just be happy with what he gives you — immense defensive value — and take what you can get with the bat for the time being while others take the lead.

All this being said, Julio deserves a break from the fans. He is incredibly talented, he is very obviously pressing, and he has shown good enough flashes to deserve our patience. It should just be in a different spot in the order, and that is not up to him. It is not his fault that he was crowned and publicized by the organization the way he was from a young age. They put immense pressure on him, and it’s not all that surprising seeing what that can do to a kid, especially when very little payroll has been invested in surrounding him.

If you want something to be mad at, be mad about the fact that Julio is continuing to be rolled out in a lineup spot that he has no business being in right now. Don’t be mad at the guy trying to figure it out.

Randy Arozarena added to AL All-Star roster

In addition to Raleigh, Rodríguez, Muñoz and Woo, Randy Arozarena has been named an All-Star as a replacement on the AL roster and the Mariners’ fifth selection. This comes in the wake of the team’s announcement that Rodríguez will not be participating in Atlanta next week.

As stated in the Compass Points section of this newsletter, Arozarena has been on fire lately. For the entire year, he has slashed .247/.354/.446 with a 132 wRC+ and 15 home runs.

Latest Transactions & Roster Moves

  • June 11: RHP Tayler Saucedo recalled from AAA Tacoma, RHP Carlos Vargas placed on the paternity list.

  • June 9: OF Jacob Hurtubise cleared waivers, outrighted to Triple-A Tacoma.

Coming up next: Detroit Tigers

Hovering just three games over .500 with one series remaining before the first half comes to a close, the Mariners will travel to Comerica Park to face the top team in baseball, the Detroit Tigers.

Coming off a brutal sweep to the Yankees, the M’s will look to stay afloat and remain right in the thick of the AL playoff race with the trade deadline rapidly approaching. As if this series didn’t already look difficult enough, they will face reigning Cy Young Award winner and Seattle University product Tarik Skull in the opening game tonight.

Date/Opponent

First Pitch

Probable Starters

7/11 @ Detroit

4:10 p.m. PDT

Luis Castillo (5-5, 3.31) vs. Skubal (10-2, 2.02)

7/8 @ Detroit

10:10 a.m. PDT

George Kirby (3-4, 4.22) vs. Mize (9-2, 2.63)

7/9 @ Detroit

10:40 a.m. PDT

Logan Gilbert (2-3, 3.88) vs. Flaherty (5-9, 4.70)

A note: tonight’s game will NOT be available on Root Sports. The game will be presented on Apple TV as part of Friday Night Baseball. The final two games of the series will be broadcast on Root Sports as normal. All three games will be available on the radio on 710 AM Seattle Sports.

This is Rolling Roof Rundown’s twice-weekly Mariners newsletter. You can follow James @rollingroofrundown.com on Bluesky and, if you haven’t already, subscribe to the newsletter for more news and commentary. Rolling Roof Rundown is now on Instagram and Threads as well.

Reply

or to participate.